Compromise bill injects "market value" into PUBLIC toll projects = highest possible tolls!

If Governor Perry and his buddy, Transportation Commission Chairman Ric Williamson, can no longer write their own ticket on private toll contracts (CDAs) due to the moratorium bill HB 1892, they decided to make PUBLIC toll entities just as insidious as private ones with a provision in the “compromise” bill SB 792. That provision is called “market valuation.” It essentially allows the PUBLIC toll entity to view the toll project as an asset (Ric Williamson’s stated goal) on the open market like these private companies do, and would handle the project like a private toll contract and determine an upfront payment to be paid to the government based on its determined worth. This is just like Cintra offering Dallas officials $2.8 billion up front for Hwy 121 in exchange for the right to collect tolls for 50 years.

In short, “market valuation” translates into the HIGHEST POSSIBLE TOLLS for our citizens, which is one of the primary complaints of using these private toll contracts.

So if this “compromise” bill, SB 792, passes with this language, the moratorium is useless since the PUBLIC toll entities would now function like these private toll companies. Dennis Enright, Public Private Partnership expert who testified at Senator John Carona’s hearing March 1, said CDAs cost 50% more and that toll projects should remain in the PUBLIC sector. But inject this “market valuation” scheme, and you end up with the same high toll escalation and increased costs to motorists as the private toll contracts. Williamson actually chided the Legislature for trying to keep the tolls as low as possible with traditional turnpikes. Instead of just selling public bonds to finance the construction of the road and charging tolls until that bond debt is retired like a traditional toll road, Perry and Williamson (and their road lobby friends) want to siphon our hard earned income into their toll road slush fund.

Our highways belong to TEXANS and they’re not “assets” for Perry or Willliamson to maximize the value of. The point of toll projects is to accelerate road projects and provide transportation not to treat them as assets for sale. Our highway system cannot infuse “market” principles. We have a limited government supply of highways; it’s not a ubiquitous product in a competitive environment like choosing between the many different types and brands of potato chips. There’s only ONE Hwy 281, and only ONE Hwy 121. This “market” approach is more akin to state run capitalism through the granting of monopolies than it is free market as they would have us believe.

Contact your State Representative NOW to ask them to change this bill!

CALL YOUR REPRESENTATIVE RIGHT NOW and ask them respectfully but firmly to:

“Stand strong in support of the provisions in HB 1892. You need to keep taxpayer protections and strip the ‘market valuation’ language in SB 792 to make this bill acceptable! Be ready to override any Governor veto.”

Find out who your reps are here.

You may contact each representative by calling the Capitol switchboard: (512) 463-4630 and/or via email below:

San Antonio State Representatives:

Rep. Joe Farias,
Rep. David Leibowitz,
Rep. Nathan Macias,
Rep. Joe Straus,
Rep. Joaquin Castro,
Rep. Trey Martinez-Fischer –
Rep. Frank Corte –
Rep. Ruth McClendon-Jones –
Rep. Jose Menendez –
Rep. Robert Puente –
Rep. Mike Villarreal –
Rep. Edmund Kuempel –

0 Replies to “Compromise bill injects "market value" into PUBLIC toll projects = highest possible tolls!”

  1. Esteban Erik Stipnieks

    For the Record Sentator Wentworth voted for SB 792 to get it out of committee and he voted for it on the floor of the Senate. At this point I for once will refrain for insulting things that clearly does not have:backbone,moral compass, ingtegrity, conviction in anything other them himself.

  2. R M Schmeisser

    As a long time resident of Bulverde Tx and user of Hwy 281 (the only available route into San Antonio) I am against the conversion to toll roads. Its really upsetting to see how you politicians have squandered the allocated assets which should have been used for over passes and now try to force us into believing that tolls are the only answer. I’m demanding that you as my elected Senator strip the compromise bill SB 792 of its language that renders the moratorium useless. I am not a wealthy person and have to use Hwy 281 to get to my job. The finacial burden this would place on so many in my situation that live out here would be devastating. This talk of leaving Hwy 281 as it is and just adding a tollway for those who choose to use it is BALONY! Hwy 281 would become an access road with probably a 40 mph limit and stop signs and red lights all the way making it an unacceptable alternative.

Leave a Reply