Citizen to TxDOT: Enron, Abramoff and the Trans Texas Corridor. Big Money, Big Manipulations, Big Mistakes.

Here are some very well stated comments to the Transportation Commission from a fellow supporter in Waller County. I couldn’t have said it better, Alice!…

I don’t understand how TxDOT can relinquish its task of right of way acquisitions for building public roads to multinational financial conglomerations whose primary interests and talents are in making and moving money. These conglomerations rival governments in their size and influence and some have argued they ARE the quasi-governments of our future. Where is the protection for the small Texas land owner, who through no fault of his own, happens to stand in the way of these devouring giants bulldozing their way through our precious countryside? What chance will any Texan have in getting fair justice when what is left of our government is nothing more than a proxy puppet for these financial institutions? Thomas Jefferson said “Governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.” But when and where did the people of Texas consent to be governed by money making corporations?

Ms. Taraborelli, the project manager for the Montgomery County Transportation Program told the Conroe Courier… Texas will be watching to see how the FM 1488 toll road project is handled. Ms. Taraborelli, employed by the private firm, Pate Engineers, went on to say the MCTP is not bound by TxDOT’s philosophy. While she may be implying that a private business may be more efficient in its operations than a governmental agency, she also seems to be suggesting that a private business may have more leeway to operate in a more aggressive way in handling environmental issues and land acquisitions. Do you sanction the public intimidation tactics used by Ms. Taraborelli toward land owners in Montgomery County?

I am very uncomfortable with the idea of a private company taking on so much of the power of the government without the same accountability to the public. It appears that this “aggressive” approach toward building Montgomery County’s new “shadow toll road” at the expense of the environment and landowners may foretell how TxDOT and its private mercenaries will handle the massive Trans Texas Corridor.

Decades from now historians will record our age as one of the most politically corrupt periods in American History rivaling the Gilded Age of the 19th century. Enron, Abramoff and the Trans Texas Corridor. Big Money, Big Manipulations, Big Mistakes.

Alice Sorsby McGuffie
Waller, Tx. 77484
Jan. 26, 2006
Presentation to Texas Transportation Commission

Casteel claims Hutchison endorses her re-election; Hutchison's office adamantly denies it!

Talk about a faux pas…

We sent out an email asking our supporters to call Senator Hutchison’s office to question why she would endorse a “toller” given the following comment by the Senator: “I’m opposed to slapping a toll on a highway that’s already built”–Texas Monthly, November 2004

Today candidate for re-election as State Representative, Carter Casteel, claimed Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison endorsed her in a hotly contested race for the 73rd District which spans Bandera, Comal, Gillespie, and Kendall counties. That’s Boerne, Bulverde, New Braunfels, Fredericksburg, Bandera and other Hill Country towns. Nathan Macias is her opponent and is committed IN WRITING to stop the tolling of existing FREEways. You can contact Senator Hutchison’s office below:

San Antonio office: 210-340-2885
Austin office: 512-916-5834
Washington DC 202-224-5922

Here’s a statement made by the Senator which is on our blog. Note the Senator’s opposition to freeway tolls yet Casteel, who voted to toll existing highways (voted for HB 2702 which proliferated tolls and actually made it legal to toll existing highways), claims Hutchison endorses her!

Excerpt from interview with Kay Bailey Hutchinson:

“Kay Bailey Hutchison”
by Evan Smith
Texas Monthly, November 2004

Q: What’s the problem with transportation? Isn’t the governor already tackling that?

“I think he’s right to prioritize transportation. We have a highway crisis. But we’ve come way too late to the importance of rail in our transit system and our urban areas. I think that rail can be a viable alternative to clogging our highways. Eighty percent of the NAFTA cars and trucks in the U.S. come through Texas. We’re helping at the federal level with the NAFTA corridors, I-69 and I-35. I put a separate fund in the highway bill for border corridors, because this is such a huge issue for us. But I don’t want a cement Texas. We cannot just pave over our urban areas. And I don’t want a toll Texas. I’m opposed to slapping a toll on a highway that’s already built. Now, if people vote a bond issue for a toll road, fine. But to build a highway with taxpayer dollars and then go in and put a toll on it and clog up the rest of the arteries in the city—it’s not right.”

Read Casteel’s press release below…

————————–

Hutchison Endorses Casteel Re-Election

U.S. Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison formally endorsed State Representative Carter Casteel (R-New Braunfels) for re-election to the Texas House today. “Carter Casteel is a conservative leader in the Texas House,” Hutchison said. “I salute Carter’s outspoken determination and heartily support her re-election this year.”

Hutchison, herself a former state representative, applauded Casteel’s public service. “Representing the Hill Country with conviction and vigor, Carter’s record demonstrates a commitment to the values that make Texas great,” Hutchison added.

“Senator Hutchison and I have worked together for the Hill Country and Texas. Her leadership in both the Republican Party and the U.S. Senate is invaluable to our state,” Casteel said. “I am honored to have her endorsement and support.”

Casteel has been previously endorsed by House Speaker Tom Craddick (R-Midland), Texas Agriculture Commissioner Susan Combs and the National Rifle Association Political Victory Fund.

Key Campaign Dates

February 6 Voter registration deadline
February 21 Early voting begins
March 7 Primary election

Political advertising paid for by the
Carter Casteel Campaign
Post Office Box 312404
New Braunfels, Texas 78131
830-627-8820 Phone
830-627-8895 Fax

——————————-

Read just two of the emails from our supporters who called Senator Hutchison’s office…

I just got off the phone with Senator Hutchinson’s office. They emphatically deny that she is in support of Carter Casteel and reiterated that she is opposed to toll roads. The person with whom I spoke with in her office made me aware that as soon as your email was out, their office has been flooded with calls concerning such. THANKS for all your hard work!

–Ray

Senator Hutchinson’s staff (San Antonio office) denies that Senator Hutchinson has endorsed Carter Casteel. They state that they (San Antonio office) have gotten no confirmation from the Senator regarding the alleged endorsement by Senator Hutchinson. I just spoke with them by phone and that is what they are saying.

–Tim

Locals battle State on 121 Tollway in Dallas, say tolls higher if State runs it

It doesn’t come as a surprise to those of us following Perry’s “innovative financing” to tolling Texas highways that local officials in Dallas are being railroaded by TxDOT in a public-private partnership takeover of the 121 toll project. Read it in the Dallas Morning News.

Here’s some of the highlights. Note how the local officials actually use some of our terms, like double taxation and taxation without representation!…

According to Frisco officials, if the state ends up in control of the project, annual tolls are expected to be more than double the amount that would be charged under a plan proposed by Collin County, Frisco, Allen, McKinney and Plano….

…Frisco Mayor Pro Tem Maher Maso noted that Texas taxpayers already paid for Highway 121’s existing lanes. But state officials are considering awarding contracts for the project to private companies, which could then set tolls as high as the market will bear, he said…

…”Not only is that double taxation, it is taxation without representation,” Mr. Maso said…

…Frisco officials estimated that state plans to use Highway 121 as a cash cow would increase initial annual tolls for a twice-a-day driver by more than $700 – not counting weekends. Mr. Purefoy argued that the highway should be available to all residents, not just those who are wealthy.
He also said that the Texas Transportation Commission wants to use excess tolls from Highway 121 in Collin County to fund other projects outside the county.

“This entire group up here is against that concept,” the city manager told the audience as he gestured toward City Council members….

…Mr. Purefoy also was critical of statements last month by Ric Williamson, chairman of the state transportation commission, who said keeping highway costs as low as possible is “not necessarily in the best interest of solving the state’s transportation dilemma” and that limiting consumers’ costs “is not our strategy.”

Mr. Purefoy said he interpreted Mr. Williamson’s comments to mean: “He calls us sheep that he wants to fleece.”

“I don’t know if that gets your blood boiling, but it does mine,” he said. “They shouldn’t be taking money out of your pocket to help fund roadways somewhere else.”

Sound familiar? Where are our local county commissioners and State legislators on this key issue that effects the future of our city? Why aren’t they defending us from this highway robbery? With only two notable exceptions, Commission Tommy Adkisson and Commissioner Lyle Larson, our local elected officials are silent and think they can avoid the issue and just cruise to re-election! Contact these tollers and our local elected officials to tell them to say “No” to Governor Perry and his Transportation Commission’s attempts to overtax the citizens of Texas to line the pockets of private interests or they’ll be escorted from office!
See who voted to toll you here!
Find out who your representatives are here.
Find your county commissioner here (commissioners appoint our local tolling authority board).

Encino Park residents furious at TxDOT for their bait & switch toll road on 281

See it here!

It was the same ol’ song and dance from TxDOT. The “you don’t have to take the toll road” line doesn’t hold water when the non-toll lanes will be frontage road with slower stop and go traffic that a foreign company can manipulate to maximize their profits! They’re taking a FREEway and replacing it with a surface street and expect us to call that “improvements!”

TxDOT admitted:

– They are, in fact, tolling the existing highway we drive on today
– The tolls won’t come off the roads…EVER!
– Both the original plan ($48 million) AND now the toll project ($83 million) are 100% paid for with gas tax money, but we won’t be able to drive on it without paying a toll, too!
– Admitted toll taxes on 281 drivers will fund more toll lanes on 1604 and other highways 281 users may not use
– That HNTB (the company the tolling authority just hired for $6.5 million to engineer toll roads on I-35, Wurzbach, and Bandera Rd) is going to conduct their new environmental assessment…can you say, conflict of interest? It never ends with these people!

A supporter videotaped the whole thing, so we’ll try to get soundbites up so you can see for yourself!

City of San Antonio admits they've "tweaked" timing of the stop lights on 281 recently!

Happenings at the MPO Meeting Monday…

Commissioner Tommy Adkisson came to the rescue right out the gate at Monday’s meeting. He asked the Board to ponder the fact that its so heavily weighted toward appointed staffers versus elected officials (7 elected out of 19). Step by step, we’re going to change the composition of that Board! He also got Citizens to be Heard to be moved from the end of the meeting to the beginning as it used to be under Commissioner Lyle Larson. Thank you Commissioner Adkisson!

THEN…

Commissioner Lyle Larson to the rescue! Many of us have noticed a marked increase in the stop light times at Stone Oak, Evans, and Encino Rio lights on US 281 literally overnight (starting last week, notably after the lawsuit stopped the 281 project). TxDOT’s on the offensive and seemed to be causing even greater traffic jams at those lights with perhaps the eventual goal to get residents to scream FOR a toll road, anything to get out of their misery! Well, we’re on to them…the same commute at the same time of day was now taking 15-20 minutes longer EVERY DAY. A resident in Big Springs had already requested stats on the timing of the lights through a public information request to TxDOT and they said they don’t control the lights at Stone Oak, Evans, or Encino Rio. The City of San Antonio does.

At the MPO meeting, Larson demanded the City cough up the rationale for changing the timing and wanted an investigation done. They tried to put it off until next month’s MPO meeting, but then he said, “No, now!” and insisted on a report on his desk right away. They grabbed Christina De La Cruz in the Public Works Dept. out of the audience to explain this. She admitted they’ve been “tweaking” it recently! The response from Larson and all of us in the audience was clear, stop messing around with our lives and get this fixed. She later grabbed us in the hall and was on the phone to her staff and told us TxDOT turned in new traffic counts and they set the lights according to those counts. Yep, we knew TxDOT was in this mix! So, thanks to our hero Lyle Larson, we should be seeing some changes ASAP! Thank him here: Commissioner Larson’s email.

Wentworth does an aboutface on tolling existing highways

Senator Jeff Wentworth’s Push Poll

Those in Senator Wentworth’s 25th District should have received his “survey” by mail. If so, note his leading questions on transportation:
1) In order to reduce congestion on our public highways, do you favor an increase in gasoline taxes of up to 50 cents per gallon to fund new highway construction?
2) In order to reduce congestion on our public highways, do you favor the construction of new highways to be paid for by tolls?

Reply to his “survey” with the facts in the comments section or in the form of a letter. If you’re a constituent and haven’t received one, contact his office and ask for one: (210) 826-7800 or email.

Many of you have already emailed us about this. Certainly his questions aren’t questions, rather they try to lead the reader to a foregone conclusion. Hence, a push poll. First of all, his office confirmed that he has no basis in fact as to the 50 cent a gallon gas tax hike. Apparently, TxDOT told him it would be a $1.00 a gallon gas tax hike! He thought that sounded too high so he put 50 cents instead. So much for a rationale, data, or facts driving these figures!

TxDOT nor Senator Wentworth can substantiate EITHER of these figures. They’re scare tactics. Even with a 50 cent per gallon gas tax hike, do the math. The average San Antonian buys about 1500 gallons of gas a year. The state gas tax is 20 cents per gallon. That would equal $300 a year. A 50 cent hike would equal $750 a year. TxDOT claims they need 5 times more money for highways ($1.00 a gallon MORE)! But let’s indulge them and assume these outrageous figures are true…that’s still less money than a lifetime of toll tax. TxDOT’s own online survey conducted by Survey Cafe quoted 29 cents a mile for a 20 mile commute on 1604. That’s $5.90 ONE WAY to work and over $3,000 a year in toll taxes.

Hmmm, give the voter this choice…stick with the gas tax system that can’t be raised without agreement of the entire legislature and signed into law by the Governor, or hand the authority to enact a whole new driving tax over to an unelected tolling board allowing them to broker secret 50 year sweetheart deals with private foreign companies to raise toll rates as high as they wish and I think the answer is obvious!

Here’s the zinger. Check out Wentworth’s own words from his own press release back in 2003…

“I am opposed to converting existing public highways into toll roads. Taxpayers have already paid for those highways and should not have to pay to drive on roads they have already paid for.”
Senator Jeff Wentworth (November 7, 2003)

Read the Senator’s press release.

Let Senator Wentworth know how you feel about his sudden change of heart about converting, US 281 and 1604, existing highways in HIS district into tollways: (210) 826-7800 or email. I thought it was a double tax, Senator? I thought you were against this? Clearly his questionnaire demonstrates he’s pushing tolls and using false and unsubstantiated information to do it!

Van Os calls on Attorney General to investigate private toll collection

NEWS RELEASE
Contact: David Van Os
david@vanosfortexasag.com
(210) 225-1955

Van Os Challenges Abbott to Fulfill His Constitutional Duty To Investigate Private Toll Collections

SAN ANTONIO, Texas, January 24, 2006 – David Van Os, unopposed in the Democratic Primary as candidate for Texas Attorney General, challenged Attorney General Greg Abbott to perform his Constitutional duty to investigate state plans for private corporations to collect tolls on public highways.

In a letter to Abbott dated Jan. 20, 2006, Van Os noted, “…Article 4 Section 22 of the Texas Constitution requires the Attorney General to ‘take such action as may be proper and necessary to prevent any private corporation from … demanding or collecting any species of taxes, tolls, freight or wharfage not authorized by law.’”

Van Os’ letter asserts: “Many Texas citizens are concerned about the anticipated usage of public authority to enable private corporations to collect toll fees for huge toll-road projects that are being planned and forecast by the Texas Department of Transportation, such as the ‘Trans Texas Corridor,’ and tolling projects in northern Bexar County involving Highway 281, Loop 1604, Interstate 10 and/or Interstate 35.”

Cintra-Zachary, a private business venture of San Antonio contractor H.B. Zachary and a Spanish company, is slated to operate the Trans Texas Corridor and Highway 281 toll-ways and collect the tolls. Since the Attorney General is Constitutionally obligated to prevent a private corporation from collecting a legally unauthorized toll, Van Os states that Abbott must investigate the planned tolling arrangements to determine their legality under all applicable laws. Since TX-DOT was recently cited for failing to conduct environmental impact studies mandated by environmental protection laws for its Highway 281 plans, there is clearly good reason for Abbott to investigate conformity with all laws before plans proceed further. As another example, Van Os points out to Abbott that, “In the case of Highway 281 in northern Bexar County, there is a specific and serious concern as to whether all legal requirements would be met for the conversion of existing freeways to toll highways.”

Van Os wants to know if Abbott has “fulfilled your Constitutional duty to investigate these planned TX-DOT projects to determine whether the planned or anticipated toll operations will be in compliance with all applicable laws, and if so, what are the results of your investigations? If you have not done so, do you intend to conduct investigations, and will you share the results with the public?” Van Os’s letter concludes by challenging Abbott: “As required of you by the Texas Constitution, I call upon you to take all necessary and proper actions to safeguard the people from the potential dangers to the public well-being posed by private toll collectors.”

As he has stated many times, David Van Os strongly believes that “Public authority should never be exploited for private gain.”

END

Toll road privatization has abysmal track record

See article in Star-Telegram.

Just a few examples (cited in the article) of deals that went south leaving taxpayers with the tab…

SR 91 Express Lanes, California — Private investors in 1995 built toll lanes in the median of a busy freeway connecting Riverside and Anaheim. A few years later, county officials wanted to expand adjacent non-toll lanes but were forbidden by a noncompete clause in their contract. SR 91 investors didn’t want non-toll roads hurting business. The county bought back the toll lanes for $208 million to clear the legal hurdle.

407 ETR, Toronto — Residents and government officials have gone to court to try to stop Madrid-based operator Cintra and its partners from raising toll rates and taking strict steps to punish motorists who use the road without paying their tolls. Because of a contract between the company and the Ontario provincial government, Cintra can block motorists from re-registering their vehicles if they haven’t paid tolls, and some residents say their credit is shot.

Cross City Tunnel, Sydney — Australians boycotted the 1.2-mile tunnel rather than pay a stiff toll, roughly $2.60 in U.S. dollars. Above ground, perfectly good lanes on city streets were shut down to try to persuade people to try the tunnel.